The Great Stone Face 1

The Great Stone Face: A Timeless Tale of Hope and Disappointment

Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Great Stone Face" is more than just a children's story; it's a profound exploration of ambition, expectation, and the elusive nature of idealization. This allegorical tale, steeped in symbolism and rich with New England charm, follows the life of Ernest, a young boy growing up in a valley overshadowed by a majestic rock formation resembling a human face. The story cleverly uses the Great Stone Face as a metaphor for our aspirations and the often-disappointing reality of achieving them. This article will delve deep into the narrative, exploring its themes, symbolism, and lasting impact, providing a comprehensive analysis suitable for readers of all backgrounds.

Introduction: The Valley of the Great Stone Face

The story unfolds in a secluded valley nestled among the New Hampshire hills. This idyllic setting, described with Hawthorne's characteristic romanticism, becomes a microcosm of human experience. The valley's inhabitants, simple and hardworking folk, share a common fascination with the Great Stone Face, a natural rock formation that dominates the landscape. The face, seemingly imbued with an almost divine presence, inspires awe and reverence. It becomes a silent observer of the valley's history and the lives of its inhabitants, including young Ernest. This setting immediately establishes the story's allegorical nature, hinting at the larger themes that will unfold. The secluded valley represents a sheltered community, while the imposing Great Stone Face embodies the idealized figures that shape their aspirations.

Ernest and the Prophecy: Shaping Expectations

Ernest, the protagonist, is a young boy deeply affected by the Great Stone Face. He's told a prophecy by his mother that one day a great man, embodying the very essence of the stone face's noble features, will emerge from the valley. This prophecy profoundly influences Ernest's life, shaping his ambitions and expectations. He devotes himself to becoming a person worthy of the prophecy, a noble and virtuous individual who would eventually fulfill the legend. This prophecy acts as a central driving force in the narrative, highlighting the powerful influence of societal expectations and the pursuit of an idealized future. It also foreshadows the potential for disappointment when reality fails to meet expectations.

The Three Candidates: Disillusionment and Reality

The narrative introduces three prominent figures who claim to embody the Great Stone Face: the ambitious politician Gathergold, the revered minister Mr. Bloodgood, and the celebrated artist Old Stony Phiz. Each of these men achieves fame and recognition in their respective fields. However, Hawthorne subtly reveals their flaws, exposing the chasm between their public image and their private character.

• Gathergold: This character embodies the pursuit of wealth and power. While initially lauded for his success, Hawthorne reveals his greed and ruthlessness, demonstrating that material success doesn't necessarily equate to true greatness. His superficial charm masks a deeply flawed character, highlighting the potential for deception and the dangers of prioritizing material wealth over moral integrity.

• Mr. Bloodgood: A charismatic and eloquent preacher, Mr. Bloodgood initially seems to exemplify the virtuous qualities associated with the Great Stone Face. However, Hawthorne exposes his hypocrisy, revealing his self-serving nature and his manipulative use of religious rhetoric. This character highlights the dangers of blind faith and the importance of critical thinking. His seemingly pious demeanor masks a manipulative and self-serving individual, demonstrating how appearances can be deceiving.

• Old Stony Phiz: The artist represents the pursuit of artistic recognition and fame. While initially admired for his talent, his character ultimately reveals a vain and egotistical nature. He is consumed by his desire for public acclaim, neglecting deeper values and ethical considerations. This character exemplifies the potential pitfalls of artistic ambition, showcasing how fame and recognition can corrupt and overshadow genuine artistic integrity.

The failure of these three individuals to truly embody the Great Stone Face serves as a crucial turning point in the narrative. It exposes the limitations of human ambition and the danger of equating external success with genuine greatness. The disappointment Ernest feels in each instance emphasizes the subjective nature of ideals and the complexity of judging character.

Ernest's Journey: Self-Discovery and Acceptance

Ernest's journey is not simply one of waiting for the fulfillment of the prophecy; it's a process of self-discovery and personal growth. His initial disappointment at the shortcomings of the three candidates prompts him to re-evaluate his own understanding of greatness. He comes to realize that the true embodiment of the Great Stone Face might lie not in external achievements but in inner qualities like compassion, integrity, and selflessness. He begins to focus on developing these qualities within himself, dedicating his life to serving others and contributing to the betterment of the community.

This shift in Ernest's perspective highlights the importance of internal growth and the development of character. He learns that true greatness lies not in outward appearances or material success but in inner virtue and moral strength. His journey underscores the idea that personal growth and self-improvement are ongoing processes, not simply destinations to be reached.

The Climax and Resolution: A Subtle Twist

The story culminates not in a dramatic revelation of a specific individual fulfilling the prophecy, but in a quiet realization. Years later, Ernest, now a mature and respected man, finds himself renowned for his kindness, wisdom, and selfless dedication to his fellow man. People from far and wide come to seek his guidance and counsel. They begin to see in him the very qualities they once associated with the Great Stone Face.

Hawthorne masterfully avoids a simplistic fulfillment of the prophecy. Instead, he offers a more nuanced and profound conclusion. The greatness Ernest embodies is not a sudden revelation but a gradual unfolding of his character. This ending subtly suggests that the Great Stone Face wasn't a representation of one specific person but rather an embodiment of the collective goodness found within humanity.

Symbolism and Allegory: Unpacking the Deeper Meanings

"The Great Stone Face" is rich in symbolism, lending itself to multiple interpretations. The Great Stone Face itself is the most prominent symbol, representing an idealized image of greatness, virtue, and nobility. This ideal, however, proves elusive and subjective, varying from person to person and changing over time.

• The Valley: Represents a sheltered community, isolated from the complexities of the outside world.

• The Prophecy: Symbolizes the powerful influence of expectations and the potential for disappointment when reality falls short.

• The Three Candidates: Represent different aspects of human ambition and the flaws inherent in the pursuit of worldly success.

• Ernest's Journey: Represents the process of self-discovery, personal growth, and the realization that true greatness lies not in external achievements but in inner qualities.

The story functions as an allegory, highlighting the dangers of idealization, the limitations of human ambition, and the importance of inner virtue. It serves as a cautionary tale, reminding us not to solely focus on outward appearances and material achievements but to cultivate inner qualities that truly define greatness.

The Enduring Legacy: Relevance in Modern Times

Despite being written in the 19th century, "The Great Stone Face" continues to resonate with readers today. Its themes of ambition, disappointment, and the search for meaning remain profoundly relevant. In a world obsessed with fame, fortune, and outward appearances, Hawthorne's story serves as a timely reminder of the importance of inner virtue and the enduring power of human compassion. The story's enduring appeal lies in its timeless exploration of human nature and its subtle yet powerful message of hope and self-discovery. The allegorical nature of the story allows readers from different backgrounds and experiences to find personal meaning and relevance within its narrative.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

• What is the central theme of "The Great Stone Face"? The central theme explores the nature of greatness, the limitations of human ambition, and the importance of inner virtue over external achievements.

• What is the significance of the Great Stone Face itself? It is a powerful symbol representing an idealized image of greatness, both subjective and elusive.

• Who are the three candidates for fulfilling the prophecy, and what do they represent? Gathergold represents the pursuit of wealth, Mr. Bloodgood the pursuit of religious power, and Old Stony Phiz the pursuit of artistic fame. They each embody different facets of human ambition and their failures expose the limitations of focusing solely on external success.

• What is the ultimate message of the story? The story ultimately suggests that true greatness lies not in external achievements but in inner qualities such as compassion, integrity, and selflessness. It emphasizes the importance of personal growth and the ongoing pursuit of virtue.

• Why is the story still relevant today? Its exploration of ambition, disappointment, and the search for meaning remains deeply resonant in a modern world that often prioritizes outward appearances and material success over inner qualities.

Conclusion: A Timeless Masterpiece

Nathaniel Hawthorne's "The Great Stone Face" is a timeless masterpiece that continues to captivate readers with its allegorical depth and enduring message. It's a story that transcends generations, offering a poignant reflection on the human condition and the complexities of the pursuit of greatness. Through its evocative imagery, subtle symbolism, and nuanced characters, the story prompts readers to contemplate their own aspirations and the true meaning of a life well-lived. The story's enduring legacy lies in its ability to spark introspection and inspire a deeper understanding of the values that truly define a meaningful and fulfilling existence. It's a story worth revisiting time and again, uncovering new layers of meaning with each rereading. The tale serves as a reminder that the journey of self-discovery and the pursuit of inner virtue are ongoing processes that ultimately shape the definition of true greatness, far beyond the fleeting allure of external accolades.